Sunday, August 17, 2008

Hear Me Roar

I have been regularly observing behaviours, comments and events around me and found them to transgress my ideas of good feminism. Most frequently I'm seeing lots of examples of women being valued, and valuing themselves, for their appearance above all other characteristics. Women who will prioritise beauty regimes above some other kind of productivity (like being at work), men who will forgive some shabby characteristics with the throwaway - but completely sincere - justification, "yeah, *shrug* but she's really hot though". I often find it difficult to butt in during these moments with a feminist critique, not least because my own feminism is often hard to pin down, it's quite fluid and complex, and seems to undergo constant evolution.

When I was a teenager and in the early years of uni I confidently took up a pretty second-wave feminist stance and would shout it loud and proud where I could. I would be quick to jump to a pretty extreme position, which was often unhelpful and untrue of my own experience. But as I delved into post-modernism and post-feminism I couldn't help but reflect that I had personally rarely suffered from overt gendered discrimination, I had lots of opportunities and I wasn't afraid to take them, and my feminism shifted to a more slippery individualistic model. Also, I know only too well the usefulness of flirting (flirting? Let's call it being charming!) a little to help get my way. But, I never fully subscribed to this theory as some of my friends did, because there are so many people who do not enjoy the priveleged, educated, position that this kind of theory assumes. And even amongst those who do I see post-feminism being used to justify an awful lot of self-interested bollocks that has nothing to do with promoting the perceptions of and rights of our gender.

Also, there's always been a lot of other confounding factors. Unlike those of my friends with more punk sensibilities, I don't want to got through life pitting myself against something or someone. And I've always taken a 'you win more flies with honey' approach to feminist opposition - so that at least people will be inclined to listen. Also another big problem has been that, like so many of us, I really want boys to like me. I want to be found attractive. It's a difficult psychological hurdle to overcome, to contradict and potentially offend/anger the very people you're hoping to appeal to. And as I observe almost daily, boys will regularly opt for less-argumentative female companions than I (although I would like to point out that I'm not I'm blaming this for why I'm single - just that it probably rules out a big chunk of the field).

But recently I've felt that I and my peers are all too lax when it comes to this stuff. The types of sexism or problematic gender roles I'm encountering are so much more insidious, and sometimes not, and not uncommonly I'm feeling pissed off at something or someone but not knowing how to point it out without creating great discord. The other problem is that nominating yourself as judge and jury presiding over the behaviour of those around you is a massive problem, and I and everyone around me is smart enough to know so. But where does that leave us?

My friends and family are as intelligent, critical, educated and decent as any people I've ever encountered - so if we can't tackle these issues then I am inclined to despair. My new policy is that a bit of discord is a price I'm willing to pay. One of the biggest obstacles my generation of women is faced with is the sense that it's all much better now than it was, even if it's not perfect, it's not so bad that it's worth upsetting a lot of people for. Bah!

I began my new campaign at a family wedding on Friday night where I had a long and engaging conversation with my uncle, who is some kind of Freemason Grand Poobah, about why they don't allow women. I pointed out that no matter how noble are the works of such an organistion, I am instinctively inclined to mistrust and resent an organisation that excludes me just because I have breasts (exquisite breasts!*). He ended up agreeing with me.

*I did not say 'exquisite breasts' to my uncle. That would just be weird.




6 comments:

ecs said...

Here here!

I wholly concur with your perspective, Tash--and find that most people define 'feminism' with second wave principles (sexual harassment, equal job/education opportunities, etc.) and therefore why they seem to conclude that the fight for equality is obsolete.

I have two quick and generally effective replies to such dismissal: 1. women are still making 76 cents to the male dollar, and 2. as long as I walk down the street at night and have to fear for my safety simply because I'm a woman, the fight isn't over.

brendan said...

"a bit of discord is a price I'm willing to pay."

gold.

nat said...

well Tash, you have done two things quite clever. A hilarious story about poo and office "etiquette" followed by your feminist rant. I got half way through until I realised I was in the midst of a political rant (a spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down)!
Secondly, by choosing a gender-based topic, my usual contrary position will inevitably put me in a position I am not sure I want to be in "online".

Nice work!

oh, DISORDER brendan? Really? Your tattoo will NEVER be justified!

nat said...

i realise discord and disorder now are not the same (as has been pointed out)but in my head they look the same. but nobody can pick on me due to mental disability. SWEET!

Unknown said...

""Well-behaved women rarely make history" - Laurel Thatcher Ulrich.

ruby

Genevieve D Berrick said...

Discord and challenge are appropriate prices to pay. And the right partners enjoy the challenge.
But honey and flies, hell yes. There's no challenge in just being 'anti'. It makes it too easy for people to dismiss and walk away. Choosing words... I have been all too aware that sometimes the wrong sentence or words can make the very palpable difference between the living and dying of people.

oh oh this was far more coherent in my head. i'll try it in person.




Note: discord / disorder - semantics aside, that tatt will remain justifiable by the number of extra giggles it brings to the women of the world.